Data Storytelling

Digital Democracy

Legislator data visuals, with a donor chart and meters for ideology, money and bill activity.

Summary

Every vote, campaign contribution, behest and gift made to a legislator, every word spoken during a hearing, and every bill amendment and redaction is tracked. There are money breadcrumbs and unexpected influences that reveal our representatives’ true colors. Problem was, this data is largely inaccessible to anyone who is not a reporter or lacks political know-how to make sense of all this data (i.e. most of us).

Project: Digital Democracy

Client: CalMatters

Platform: WordPress

Role: UX Lead

Activities:

  • Scope planning
  • Discovery workshops
  • Research
  • Data storytelling & visualization
  • Prototyping
  • User testing

Data Storytelling

The goals for this project were:

  1. Use the deep government data to tell meaningful data stories that an average citizen can find interesting and insightful.
  2. Create research tools for deeper investigation into never-before possible relationships, transactions, and potential stories.

Video still of several people at a table, with one person working on a tablet.

🏆 Accolades

Soon after launching, Digital Democracy was featured in a CBS investigative story.

Digital Democracy website and CBS News collaboration won Emmy award, honoring accountability journalism that, as one reporter described, “I could not have done” without Digital Democracy.

Discovery & Scope Planning

The client had a vision that included several interconnected products, a vision that we’ve helped them refine over several workshops:

  • Digital Democracy - CA legislation for dummies: A curated, condensed guide to help voters get to know their 120 legislators to help them with their voting decision
  • Tip Sheets: Summaries of legislative hearings. Tool to help reporters find ideas for their stories based on recent legislative hearings
  • Search: A way to explore a vast ocean of legislative data. Comprehensive research tool for those interested in deeper investigation (think query builder).

Conceptual Models & Foundational Architecture

Visual diagrams help frame discussions. One model that was useful is a spoon<->bucket spectrum, symbolizing the depth of legislative information the different products made available to the user.

This led to the idea of Digital Democracy’s primary pages catering to general voters with highly curated (i.e. spoon fed) content with ability for deeper dives into the database (i.e. U-pick bucket to do your own research), while Tip Sheets become a separate gated product for beat reporters.

Workshop board that maps how the Digital Democracy products relate within one ecosystem.

Architecture diagram that shows how Digital Democracy, Expert Search and Tip Sheets share data.

User profile sheet for activists, with their goals, needs, expectations and key messages.

Audience research

The budget for any external research was mostly nonexistent, so we’ve worked with what we had, and what we had was an easy access to reporters. We ran interviews and held audience discovery workshops with the client and compiled the findings in several user profile sheets.

Stories & Feature Prioritization

We’ve used the insights from the interview with reporters along with client’s list of feature ideas to put together a comprehensive table of user stories, and ran several prioritization and brainstorming workshops to narrow in the current scope and budget.

User stories table that lists features and the audience for each story.

Prioritization board that ranks features by business priority and user priority.

Content Ecosystem Mapping

With literally hundreds of data points available to pull from, the question of what data is relevant to which user and what data stories we want to tell them became our driving inquiry and instigated the need to understand the larger picture of state legislature.

One exercise that helped was a collaborative ecosystem workshops to map out the relevant data entities available to us for storytelling. It was messy, but it helped us understand the relationships between legislature, people, and organizations, and how money and influence flowed within the political ecosystem.

Content ecosystem map that links bills, legislators, lobbyists and organizations.

Legislator profile wireframe with a bio, badges and meters for ideology, activity and money.

“A really large baseball card”

The MVP players in state government are the legislators, and so much of the political activity revolves around them. We wanted to create a homepage (a.k.a. baseball card) of each legislator that brought high-value, easy-to-understand information to general voters.

Examples of techniques we’ve used:

  • We used meters to show legislator’s real ideology (based on their voting patterns), how active/sedentary their political activity was (based on hearing attendance, committee membership, bill initiation, etc.), and money tracker indicating how much money they attracted.
  • We’ve assigned leader badges to identify major topic influencers
  • Alignment rankings showed idealogical alignment with organizations from different sectors.

Alignment rankings that show how often a legislator votes with organizations in each sector.

💡 User Insight

We’ve put a leaderboard feature on the homepage as a discovery tool for general voters. What we didn’t intend is that legislators themselves started using them for friendly competitions.

One legislator even brought it up during a public hearing!

Legislator leaderboard ranked by words spoken, with filters for other rankings.

A smattering of rabbit holes

Building on our spoon/bucket analogy, beyond being well-informing, we wanted our baseball cards to act as springboards into various rabbit holes for deeper investigation. With our flows, you could follow the money trail or virtually stalk a legislator until you stumble across fascinating insights (like the CBS story).

One progressive disclosure technique we’ve used to accomplish this are the various side modals that allowed users to glean deeper levels of information and provide signposts to the deepest-level search and entity detail pages.

Three side panels for an organization's votes, contact options and bill details.

More Storytelling Concepts

Concept for a grid of legislator faces that expands to show details, on desktop and mobile.

Concepts that show all legislators as dots in a half circle and in a grid, with filters.

Ranking concept that lists legislators by an ethics score, with tabs for other measures.

Financials concept with election money, influence money and total funds for a legislator.

Education bills concept with featured bills and a filterable list of related bills.

Poster frame for a video about the donor chart and campaign money totals for a legislator.

Final design of the ideology, bill activity and money tracker meters on a legislator page.

Legislator page with a side panel open that shows the ACLU's vote alignment history.

Screens

Full homepage wireframe with California topics, a legislator grid and top 10 lists.

Full topic page wireframe about higher education, with bills and key players.

Full legislator profile wireframe with news, politics, financials and district sections.

Hearing page design with a video, a searchable transcript and the bills on the agenda.

Bill page design with a status timeline, bill text and the hearings where it was discussed.

Live Digital Democracy homepage with an introduction and a database search box.